Straight to the Level
The GE Profile Smart Mixer is a strong stand mixer that performs properly in any respect the duties a standard mixer ought to be capable to. However its “sensible” options received in the best way greater than they helped, and it won’t be well worth the $800 price ticket.
They’re large, they’re cumbersome, they usually take up loads of counter house, however for some essential duties, they’re an irreplaceable software within the kitchen. We’re, after all. speaking about stand mixers. And with the GE Profile Smart Mixer, we’re promised a stand mixer that streamlines the method with a couple of “sensible” options. The primary is an inside scale that senses weight in two locations: on the round base of the mixer in addition to with the arms that maintain the bowl. However the one characteristic that actually makes it “sensible” is the app in your cellphone that sends instructions, mixing speeds, and instances to the mixer. The app additionally gives guided recipes that ship instructions step-by-step to the mixer, in addition to “auto-sense” recipes by which the mixer displays modifications in viscosity and adjusts mixing speeds and instances accordingly.
We put this mixer by way of quite a lot of assessments to see how properly its scale and sensible options labored, and if they really made baking any easier. We additionally examined the way it functioned in comparison with analog-style mixers.
- Whipping Cream Check: We used the built-in scale to weigh out heavy whipping cream into the bowl, set a timer, and whipped the cream at medium-high pace, stopping the timer when the cream was fluffy and thick. We then famous how simple the bowl was to take away from the machine and to deal with whereas emptying the whipped cream right into a container.
- Pound Cake Check: We used the “auto-sense” recipe for “Lemon Bliss Cake” within the app, which comes from King Arthur Baking, as all the opposite recipes do. We adopted the instructions for the guided recipe, measuring out elements utilizing the built-in scale, mixing in elements when and the way it advised us to, and noting if it ever made “auto-sense” changes to timing and pace. In fact, we ate the cake to see if it was well-aerated.
- Pizza Dough Check: We adopted our recipe for Neapolitan pizza, utilizing the app to set a timer, and the built-in scale to weigh elements. We famous whether or not or not the machine struggled to knead the powerful dough, and if the dough rode up on the dough hook. We additionally recorded how tough it was to take away dough from the bowl.
- Usability and Cleansing: All through the course of testing, we famous how simple or tough it was to make use of every of the mixer’s options or components, and likewise how simple the bowl and attachments had been to wash.
What We Discovered
The Sensible Options had been Glitchy
This stand mixer can perform similar to a traditional stand mixer, however the actual worth proposition is in its accompanying cellphone app and “auto-sense” know-how. By means of the app, you join your cellphone to the mixer through WiFi, after which ship instructions to it, reminiscent of setting a timer, turning it on to a sure pace, or setting it to run at a sure pace for a sure time. The app can also be geared up with two sorts of recipes: “auto-sense” recipes and guided recipes. With guided recipes, the app takes you step-by-step by way of the recipe, sending all of the timing and pace directions to the mixer. “Auto-sense” recipes are similar to guided recipes, however on this case, sensors within the mixer’s motor monitor the combination’s viscosity and make modifications to timing and pace for optimized emulsion and incorporation. On the time of writing, there are solely 13 “auto-sense” recipes (considered one of which is solely creaming sugar and butter, which allegedly takes 68 minutes) and about 32 guided recipes. This looks as if too few recipes total contemplating the primary promoting level of the sensible mixer is that this characteristic.
Constructed-in options like a timer and digital scales within the bowl arms and the bottom of the mixer, along with a timer perform, add to its purported intelligence over different mixers. Apart from that, the GE Profile Sensible mixer works like a traditional planetary-style stand mixer (which means the beater spins whereas transferring across the mounted bowl in a circle). Not like a tilt-head mixer, the place the entire prime flips up or down, it is a bowl-lift mixer, the place two holes on both facet of the bowl hook into the mixer’s arms which are then lifted up and locked into place with adjoining levers.
The app additionally works with Alexa or Google Residence gadgets, so you’ll be able to converse instructions to the machine in case your arms are soiled or occupied doing another process. This labored with my Google Residence, nevertheless it solely responded to 3 instructions “Hey Google, set the stand mixer pace to [0-11]”, “Hey Google, set stand mixer route to ahead/reverse.” and “Hey Google, set the stand mixer to off.” To show the stand mixer to any pace from off, you should utilize voice management, however it can solely begin when you press the button within the heart of the stand mixer’s management panel. You’ll be able to flip the pace down or fully off, or into reverse with only a voice command, no must press something. However for some cause, we weren’t capable of flip the pace up through voice command in any respect. General, this was a clunky characteristic that required particular instructions, so we don’t assume it’s useful.
The Constructed-In Scales and Timers Had been Handy-ish
Two scales are constructed into this mixer: one within the arms that maintain the bowl up, and one on the round base of the mixer. The one on the bottom works with any bowl or vessel, not simply the blending bowl, however they’re each programmed into the guided and “auto-sense” recipes. In all of the recipes on the app, the instructions inform you so as to add nonetheless a lot of an ingredient, and the mixer’s display will present you the way a lot you’ve added earlier than beeping if you’ve hit the mark.
You too can use the dimensions impartial of the app, however we discovered that this was barely extra finicky, and, surprisingly, there was a few 5-gram distinction between the 2 scales when weighing the very same object. The size perform solely goes by intervals of 5 grams (it additionally reveals kilos, ounces, and kilograms) which isn’t almost as exact as any digital kitchen scale—and baking is all about precision. We needed to reset the dimensions a couple of instances because it stored flashing “overload.” Sometimes, when the arms had been within the lowered place, the dimensions had bother resetting to zero and simply reverted again to the tared weight of the bowl.
Whilst you’re mixing, it’s good to not must take away the bowl, soiled one other measuring cup, or get away your personal digital scale, however since you need to actually measure your elements out beforehand in any baking or cooking endeavor, we’re somewhat iffy on how helpful this characteristic is.
As for the timer, the app’s recipes ship timing information straight to the mixer, however you continue to must manually press the middle button on the mixer to make it go, so it’s not really distant. You’ll be able to’t set a timer by way of the app except the mixer can also be stirring, which is annoying, however you’ll be able to set a timer if the mixer is in analog mode. Additionally, when altering the timer remotely, you need to cancel mixing altogether and begin over with new instructions.
It Combined Effectively
General, this mannequin dealt with its fundamental job properly. The bottom (“stir”) and highest pace (11) are each slower and quicker, respectively, than these of my KitchenAid Artisan. Having a really sluggish pace is nice when including powdery, dry elements or liquids that quick beaters may puff up in a cloud or splash out of the bowl. That being stated, its quickest pace is very quick. When kneading thick pizza dough on pace two for 10 minutes, the mixer fitted with a dough hook by no means struggled or received heat from overheating. Nevertheless, throughout kneading, the bowl stored popping up and down barely, going out and in of its lock on the bottom of the mixer. In any other case, although, the bowl stayed put.
The attachments are fairly commonplace: a paddle, a whisk, and a dough hook. The paddle reached the underside and the edges of the bowl properly, guaranteeing virtually every little thing was included. The whisk has a whopping 11 tines (as in, full loops) whereas my KitchenAid solely has six. This made it extraordinarily highly effective (possibly too highly effective) for duties like whipping one cup of cream, because it had a bent to overwhip. Nevertheless, we favored that the whisk has a gap giant sufficient for a hand to get in there to wash, in contrast to different whisk attachments. For duties like beating egg whites and sugar into a meringue, it might be excellent. The dough hook was completely curved to wrangle pizza dough, and it prevented the widespread pitfall of the dough climbing up the hook and getting caught on the prime. It additionally launched the dough properly, with virtually no sticking. Plus, the bowl top is adjustable, so if there’s house on the backside of the bowl the place elements aren’t getting included by an attachment, you’ll be able to elevate the bowl barely by turning a screw on the bottom of the mixer.
The attachments are all stainless-steel, in contrast to another manufacturers which have enamel-coated paddles and dough hooks (whisks are virtually at all times metal). Enamel-coated attachments typically chip (mine started chipping after a couple of years of use), however stainless-steel doesn’t have that drawback. One other distinctive characteristic was the locking mechanism that affixes the attachments to the mixer. Not like KitchenAid mixers, which have a push and twist spring-lock, these attachments simply require one push to lock in. To eject them, you need to pull down on the cylinder above they usually fall down into the bowl. The falling half was barely annoying since they sometimes received extra batter on them which then needed to be scraped off, nevertheless it was good to not must decrease the bowl arms to retrieve the attachments.
Who Is This Mixer For?
That is the query that loomed over most of our assessments. If you happen to’re a newbie baker, options like step-by-step instructions within the guided recipes and the promise of “auto-sense” recipes the place some mixing guesswork is eradicated, may very well be useful. I may see how breaking it down into steps for the consumer, as a substitute of simply being bombarded by a wall of recipes, does make the educational curve of baking extra manageable. Plus, when you’re at all times forgetting elements or steps, the app helps forestall that (that being stated, the app’s recipe for Lemon Bliss Cake did neglect to inform the consumer to incorporate the lemon zest within the instructions). This characteristic might make baking simpler when you’re simply beginning out, however most newbie bakers don’t want a high-powered, heavy-duty mixer with raise arms and a 7-quart bowl (most stand mixers have a 5-quart bowl, which is often a lot for home-baking purposes). And at $800, I can’t think about anybody considering it is a good “starter” mixer.
A lot of the advertising is dedicated to the thought you could set it and neglect it, strolling away to do one thing else whereas the mixer adjusts its time and pace and stops when it’s carried out. Nevertheless, you need to at all times be keeping track of what’s taking place in your mixing bowl lest your whipped cream curdles, your batter turns into overworked, and so on. Second, when you’re not a professional, you’re in all probability baking for leisure, by which case you don’t really need the fulfilling expertise of blending to be totally automated.
If you happen to’re an skilled and even intermediate baker, you already know that baking is about greater than numerical values for instances and speeds; it’s about understanding what cues to search for along with your senses. That’s why good recipes say “Combine till the final streaks of flour disappear” not simply “Combine for 3 minutes on low pace.” Completely different mixers have various energy settings and, relying on quite a few components, three minutes is perhaps an excessive amount of or too little time. So an skilled baker would in all probability discover these bells and whistles superfluous, or worse, annoying and in the best way. As an skilled baker, I can say that the “auto-sense” recipe for Lemon Bliss Cake produced a terrific cake, however I couldn’t assist however surprise what would have occurred if I had intervened when it beat the eggs for for much longer than it took to mix them with the butter and sugar; or when it stirred too quick for alternating including moist and dry elements; or when it blended the ultimate batter too quick and well past the purpose that it was totally mixed.
This mixer was very highly effective (540 watts) and didn’t battle when kneading a thick, powerful pizza dough on low pace. The GE Profile goes in control 11, whereas most mixers don’t go previous 10, and its “stir” pace was considerably slower than my Kitchen-Assist Artisan, which gave me rather more management when including flour or liquids that may simply find yourself in your shirt and never within the bowl. At decrease speeds like “stir,” even as much as 4 or 5, it was very quiet.
Not like another manufacturers’ enamel-coated attachments, GE makes use of a chrome steel paddle, whisk, and dough hook, that are simpler to identify dust on and clear—and likewise aren’t vulnerable to put on and tear like chipping and flaking. They had been additionally very simple to pop on and off with a easy push-and-pull lock mechanism. We additionally favored you could regulate the peak of the bowl (essential to ensure every little thing is included by the beater) with a screw that’s situated on the bottom of the mixer. Because it blended, the beater reached virtually all the best way to the underside and the edges of the bowl, leaving only a skinny layer of unincorporated elements, which is spectacular for not having a bowl scraper attachment.
The guided recipes made utilizing the mixer a lot simpler since every little thing is pre-programmed with the load of elements, mixing speeds, and timers. This appeared to be the one time the scales and timers labored seamlessly, and it additionally meant that it was laborious to neglect any elements or steps. The “auto-sense” guided recipe for Lemon Bliss Cake resulted in a well-emulsified batter and a cake that was fluffy and tender — not powerful from being overworked.
When it labored, the digital scale perform was handy, and we favored how the hole between the mixer and the lip of the bowl was giant sufficient to pour a number of elements in. We additionally favored how the excessive sides of the bowl prevented dry elements from puffing up and moist elements from forking out.
The app was simple to arrange and pair over WiFi with the mixer and Google Residence (for voice management).
The sensible options on this mixer had been nice in principle, however not in follow, and the educational curve on all of the digital bells and whistles was steep. The size and timer features had been each finicky and solely labored underneath sure situations. Additionally, the dimensions solely recorded grams in intervals of 5, and, relying on the place the bowl was (on the bottom or within the bowl arms), the dimensions was off by about 5 grams when measuring the very same quantity. Sending instructions from our cellphone to the mixer whereas the beaters weren’t transferring required us to press a button on the mixer, which sort of defeats the aim of getting a distant management (except you’re making a guided recipe).
And talking of the guided recipes, as I discussed earlier than, there are solely about 45 on the app presently, 13 of that are “auto-sense”. The auto-sense recipe for Lemon Bliss Cake turned out nice, however we’re not ready to say that was due to any changes made by the viscosity sensors within the mixer (we seen no modifications in timing or pace throughout mixing). We additionally seen that the app’s recipe did neglect to inform the consumer so as to add the lemon zest. Surprisingly, there wasn’t an choice to activate a timer for baking within the oven whereas doing a guided recipe.
One other part of the app that made us scratch our heads was the “Lively Stir Beta” mode that makes you turn from distant to handbook to make use of it, however then it will not perform and tells you to change again to distant. Clearly, it’s within the beta stage, however typically it appeared like all of the digital components of this mixer had been.
As for the voice management, it labored, however solely with very particular instructions that we had bother remembering. Plus, it solely labored for sure duties, like turning the mixer on (although you continue to must press a button on the mixer), reversing the beaters, turning it down, or turning it off. We weren’t capable of flip the pace up in any respect or set a timer through voice command.
Additionally, this mixer is heavy—like actually heavy. I’m 5’11” and 200 kilos and struggled to raise it, so I wouldn’t suggest it to anybody who desires to retailer a mixer someplace aside from your countertop. Although it was pleasantly quiet at low speeds, at larger than six or seven, it was louder than my 12-year-old KitchenAid (which desperately wants a service). Its most decibel stage is 75, which is about as loud as a vacuum cleaner.
Lastly, there’s no getting round it: with an $800 price ticket, we aren’t certain it is well worth the $270 greater than our favourite non-smart stand mixer that performed just as well.
- Weight: Precise: 38.4 lbs; with bowl: 41 lbs; with bowl and all attachments: 43.4 lbs
- Dimensions: 11.33 x 14 x 17.07 inches
- Acknowledged bowl capability: 7 quarts
- Wattage: 540 watts
- Attachments: Paddle, dough hook, whisk, splash/pouring protect
- Care directions: Paddle, whisk, dough hook, protect, and bowl are dishwasher-safe
- Supplies: Chrome steel bowl and attachments, plastic splash protect
- Value at time of publish: $800
Do you want a smartphone to make use of the GE Profile?
No, the mixer works similar to a standard mixer when not in distant mode. To make use of all of its options like setting timers and pace management remotely, utilizing “auto-sense” and guided recipes, and voice management, you need to obtain the Sensible HQ app, join the mixer to your WiFi, and pair the app along with your mixer.
What does the GE Profile include?
The GE Profile Stand Mixer comes with a paddle, dough hook, and whisk attachment, in addition to a plastic protect that guards towards splashes and options a gap for pouring in elements.
What are stand mixers good for?
Generally stand mixers are a requirement for recipes, and typically they only make issues a lot, a lot simpler. For instance, a stand mixer is ideal for making a cake batter by which you need to stream in liquid or dry elements whereas the mixer is operating. One can even turn out to be useful when you’re tasked with kneading a thick bread dough for a very long time. Stand mixers are additionally nice for Swiss meringue buttercream, the place sizzling sugar and egg whites have to combine on excessive pace for 10 minutes (typically extra) till they cool off and you may add the butter. Actually, we’re speaking about any recipe that requires one combination to be blended into one other whereas the combination is operating, or any recipe that requires mixing or kneading for prolonged durations of time.
Why We are the Consultants
- Eric King is a recipe developer, photographer, meals stylist, and content material creator. He runs a baking weblog referred to as easygayoven and has developed, styled, and photographed recipes for Netflix Household. He is been writing for Critical Eats for a few yr.
- For this overview, we used the GE Profile to make whipped cream, pound cake, and pizza dough. All through testing we additionally examined how simple the app and sensible options had been to make use of and in the event that they added any worth to the stand mixer’s usability.
- We have reviewed stand mixers and much more KitchenAid stand mixers, so we all know a factor or two concerning the equipment.